It seems to me that anything that the Illinibucks can be
applied to would be something the students would use them for. The main
possible uses that come to mind would firstly be to move to the head of the
line at any on-campus food provider, so for example using one would allow you
to move to the front of the line at Chipotle. I think that this use would work
pretty well, especially if students were only given a set amount of Illinibucks
and could not buy more, because that means that students don’t have to wait in
line when they are in a hurry, however the set number means that it won’t be
impossible to get food if you are waiting in line, because only so many people
will want to use up their Illinibucks at that particular time.
Another possible use would be that these would allow someone
to go to the front of the line at bookstores as well as food providers, which
would be especially handy at the beginning of the semester when everyone is
purchasing books and the lines at the Illini Bookstore and TIS tend to get
extremely long. Once again, though, if some people were able to get more
Illinibucks than others because they could afford more, it would put the
students would couldn’t at a disadvantage because they would likely have to
wait in line even longer without having the added benefit of being able to, at
least to some degree, predict how much longer the line will be like students
have now.
A third possible use would be to jump ahead in registering
for classes. This would change the allocation method from being based on your
year in school, any possible honors programs, and your major. I think that this
would be particularly ineffective, because it would make it more difficult for
students who need a class, for example a senior who needs a particular class
for their major, to get into the course.
I personally think that in all of these circumstances the llinibucks
would work better if everyone was given a set amount, rather than being allowed
to purchase them. If students were able to purchase as many as they wanted,
then there is the potential that Illinibucks become almost necessary in order
to get to the front of whatever line the situation involves, because if one
student doesn’t use them, they will just have to wait longer because so many
other students will. I personally would
spend my Illinibucks when I did not have the time to wait in a line, or if they
were used for class registration, when it was a class I urgently needed. I
would try to not waste them because I have a limited budget and would want to
avoid ever having to buy more.
If the administered price was too low, there would be an
issue with Illinibucks becoming the norm as I mentioned above. A majority of
people would use them fairly frequently, and the more people that used them,
the more beneficial it would become to use one yourself. If the administered
price was too high, then they could serve as a differentiator between students
who have enough money to feel comfortable spending it in that way (or who’s
parents have enough money), and students who don’t. This seems unfair to me,
however this would not be the only place where money serves as a divided in
that aspect, and so it would probably seem normal if this policy was administered.
I like your idea about providing a set number of Illinibucks to each student. That way the students could use the Illinibucks for their preferences and not have to face the income gap problem. I completely agree that if students could buy as many as they wanted, that students who couldn't afford the Illinibucks would be further disadvantaged by having to wait much longer in line or not getting to register for the classes they wanted.
ReplyDeleteThe fixed amount per student was the intent. Further the administered prices might vary from one use to another. Students would have to learn the pricing. But once they got adjusted to it, they could plan accordingly.
ReplyDeleteLike your classmates you wrote about seniors needing courses to graduate. My question is - why don't they already have those courses on their transcript? Why are they waiting for them when they are a senior? if the answer is because they couldn't get into them earlier, that would seem a problem that the Illinibucks might address.